Tequila Pantalones Añejo Organico

89 SCORE

“This was better than I expected. The notes are of oak, honey and butterscotch. It has a sweet flavor of oak and butterscotch with a descent finish. There is still a small rasp to it, but finishes fairly smoothly.”

Herradura Legend

78 SCORE

“It smells of oak, vanilla butterscotch and alcohol. The taste is good, oaky with hints of vanilla and caramel. There’s a bit of a rasp/alcohol finish, but it’s not overpowering and finishes fairly smoothly.”

Cincoro Tequila Gold

88 SCORE

“The nose is very good, sweet, caramel and vanilla notes. The taste is more subtle than the anejo version, but smoother in finish overall. A very interesting trade off.”

Codigo 1530 Origen Extra Añejo

57 SCORE

“The smell is strong oak and a bit of alcohol. The taste matches the nose, strong oak flavor and has a bit of a harsh rasp. Not smooth enough for its price point in my opinion. ”

Number Juan Extra Añejo

68 SCORE

“The nose is descent, sweet. The taste is pretty good, with hints of vanilla, butterscotch and oak. The rasp is more pronounced than I prefer. I expected it to be smoother. ”

Asombroso Vintage Añejo 11 Year

91 SCORE

“Beautiful scent of caramel, vanilla, toffee and butterscotch. Smooth finish with tastes of vanilla and caramel. A bit over priced but an excellent tequila. ”

Asombroso El Carbonzado

90 SCORE

“Beautiful scent, sweet, notes of butterscotch and caramel. Wonderfully smooth finish and great legs.”

AsomBroso Especial De Rouge Extra Añejo

60 SCORE

“The smell was sweet and wonderful. However, the taste was mostly alcohol with a harsh rasp. Not sure if I got a bad bottle or what. The legs on it where very fast, which is not typical of this version of Asombroso. The Gran Reserva is better at 1/4 the price. ”

Avión Reserva Cristalino

67 SCORE

“Definitely not as good as Avion 44, which is currently cheaper around me. It lost some of the flavor 44 has and has more of a rasp, which makes it not as smooth as 44 either. Not a terrible tequila, just another example of jumping on the crystalino bandwagon. ”

Cava de Oro Extra Añejo

92 SCORE

“This is a sweet tequila, with hints of caramel and vanilla. I have a significant sweet tooth, so I’m a large fan. Not as sweet as Adictivo (same distillery), just a notch down from it, but sweeter than Clase Azul’s Reposado. Excellent, smooth finish. ”

Gran Patrón Piedra

88 SCORE

“I’m not a Patron fan, but this is a great tequila. Excellent aroma and a beautiful finish. Very smooth all the way around. The only down side is the cost, it’s about triple it’s true worth. ”

Don Julio Primavera

62 SCORE

“I find the rasp on this to harsh, the alcohol came through just a bit too much. I’d rather drink 70 or regular DJ anejo which both cost way less.”

Adictivo Tequila Extra Añejo Black

98 SCORE

“I love this very sweet, exceptionally smooth tequila. However, I’m not sure I can tell the difference between this and Adictivo’s normal extra anejo, and I’ve put them against each other.”

Adictivo Tequila Extra Añejo Cristalino

95 SCORE

“I’m slightly biased, I love Adictivo’s extra anejo to start. The crystalino’s filter process removed a bit of the caramel flavor, but it is still very sweet with an exceptionally smooth finish. Diehard tequila fans will most likely not like the sweet taste, but it totally agrees with my sweet tooth.”

Adictivo Tequila Extra Añejo

98 SCORE

“This is probably one of the sweetest tequilas I have tasted, but it matches my sweet tooth perfectly. Caramel, Vanilla and toffee notes come through in a very smooth finish. ”

Teremana Tequila Reposado

70 SCORE

“The first thing I noticed was the alcohol scent, which carries over onto the flavor and finish. It’s still decently smooth, but the alcohol presence is a touch too strong for my taste. There is a nice agave flavor and notes of caramel and oak. For $37, it was more than worth a try and will make excellent drinks, but not a sipping choice.”

Clase Azul Reposado

94 SCORE

“This is a repasado that drinks like an Añejo. It has a beautiful aroma with hints of toffee and vanilla. I can just sit and smell the glass when I’m finished. The taste is sweeter than most with notes of caramel, vanilla, and toffee, which is probably why most experts rate it lower. It has an extremely smooth finish. This is my current favorite sipping tequila by far.”

Herradura Seleccion Suprema

86 SCORE

“I greatly enjoy Suprema, but it’s not a value buy. There are similar and better tequilas for $200 less. That said, it’s aroma and taste both have hints of sweet caramel and toffee. It is smooth, but there are smoother at lower price points.”

Avion Reserva 44

93 SCORE

“44 is one of my favorites. The aroma is excellent, I could smell the glass all night. The taste is smooth and sweet with hints of caramel, toffee and vanilla. It is one of my staples and is always on hand. I’ve tasted it next to several more expensive bottles and it is always better.”

Cincoro Tequila Añejo

85 SCORE

“It has a ver sweet aroma. It has a very strong flavor palate compared to most tequilas. Hints of butterscotch, toffee and spice. Smooth finish. I will keep it on hand.”