Terralta Tequila Extra Añejo

90 SCORE

“Really an explosion of flavors. Then the flavor dissipates and sits on your tongue for an extended period of time. Every sip has me questioning what flavors I’m experiencing. There’s definitely a flavor in the beginning I cannot put my finger on… my tequila vocabulary doesn’t seem developed enough to put a finger on it but then it moves to butter scotch and vanilla. Great tequila for the price ”

El Mayor Extra Añejo

92 SCORE

“My goodness what an explosion of flavors. On the swallow the flavors from the bourbon barrels are immediate. The agave sits on your tongue and it goes down so smooth. Every sip is such a unique flavor experience. Very good stuff”

Pasote Extra Añejo

65 SCORE

“There’s a lot of fruity notes but I find this rough around the edges. Not something that I truly enjoy sipping. Don Pippocho has spoiled me ”

Tears of Llorona Extra Añejo

86 SCORE

“Had this at Besitos in Tampa. It seems a bit watered down but the flavors are absolutely there and amazing. Very complex . Every sip I think about what I’m tasting and can’t nail it. Very very intriguing tequila. Highly recommend ”

1800 Edicion del Nuevo Milenio Añejo

93 SCORE

“Absolutely splendid. Smooth. Caramel tones that linger. No burn. Butter scotch and vanilla notes. Absolutely incredible ”

Casa Maestri Reserva de MFM Añejo

65 SCORE

“Almost tastes like it’s watered down. There’s an alcohol burn at the end and a tingling on the tongue but not very flavorful. Highly disappointed with this tequila, especially for the price. ”

Tres Generaciones Añejo Tequila

82 SCORE

“Smooth. No burn. Creamy. Hints of vanilla. Good price. Would do again. ”

Eight Reserve Añejo

71 SCORE

“It’s a interesting flavor. Slight alcohol at first and then a creamy after taste. Slight tingle on the tongue. I believe this isn’t the best tequila and way over priced ”

Asombroso Gran Reserva Ultra Añejo

81 SCORE

“Has a creaminess to it. Tingles the tongue. Warm going down but doesn’t burn. Interesting smoothness. Very expensive though”

Cazadores Tequila Añejo

74 SCORE

“Interesting flavor profile. Has a mild agave burn but smooth going down. Warms up your soul. Hints of vanilla. Not the smoothest, a decent bargain Anejo ”

Cazcanes No. 7 Añejo

92 SCORE

“Smooth smooth smooth. Vanilla, agave. Lingers on the tongue. Absolutely delicious ”

Don Fulano 20 Aniversario Sherry Cask Añejo

91 SCORE

“Hints of vanilla. Smooth with a warm finish. Great tequila!”

Nueveuno Tequila Añejo

90 SCORE

“Great smooth tequila. Leaves a nice agave tingle on the tongue after the sip. Delicious ”

1800 Cristalino Añejo

76 SCORE

“I love the after taste of caramel and agave. However this tequila leaves a lot to be desired. ”

Tierra Noble Exquisito Extra Añejo

93 SCORE

“Incredibly smooth. Caramel flavors. Leaves a tingling on the tongue. Very interesting flavor profile. The agave is smooth with lots of notes I can’t quite put my finger on but incredible. Smells like butter scotch and a hint on butter scotch. It makes you want to keep sipping it to experience all of the flavors ”

Clase Azul Reposado

79 SCORE

“This is interesting. It’s definitely not as smooth as an Anejo. It does not warm you up as it goes down. The flavor lingers at the top front of your mouth. There’s a bite on the first swallow, then hints of vanilla and a rougher tequila flavor. It’s not a bad repasado, but cannot compare to the anejos I normally drink ”

Komos Tequila Añejo Cristalino

83 SCORE

“There’s a silkyness to this tequila. It is smooth. There’s a hint of caramel. Vanilla. It’s a good tequila, you can tell it’s pure”

Casamigos Tequila Añejo

68 SCORE

“The flavor is interesting. It tastes like it is watered down and then there’s a bite at the end. The flavor profile of the tequila is meh. No good notes. It leaves a tingle on your tongue afterwards which seems strange.”

Don Julio Añejo

79 SCORE

“It’s got a bite when you first sip it. Goes down smooth and warm. It’s a good entry level into Anejo tequila or if that’s all that’s available at a bar, but there are definitely better options ”

Lote Maestro Extra Añejo

85 SCORE

“Look, this tequila tastes like rum and it’s good. However you can tell this is not a pure tequila. There are additives. The purist in me says this tequila should be a 60 or 65 out of 100. The casual drinker in me that just wants a smooth tequila to sip on with friends says this is an 85 or 90. ”